Karen Read Case: Dog Bites & Cover-Up? New Details Emerge...

Dan Koss PhD 10 May 2025

Is the official narrative surrounding the death of Boston Police Officer John O'Keefe a complete fabrication, or is there a far more sinister truth hidden beneath the surface? The evidence, as presented by the defense in the Karen Read case, suggests a shocking cover-up, pointing the finger at O'Keefe's colleagues and raising serious questions about the integrity of the investigation.

The story, as it has been officially presented by the police and the Norfolk County District Attorney's office, paints a clear picture: Karen Read, O'Keefe's girlfriend, intentionally ran him over with her SUV while attempting a three-point turn outside 34 Fairview Road in Canton, Massachusetts, leaving him to die in the snow. This is the narrative the prosecution is relentlessly pursuing, a narrative that is now being challenged by the defense, who claim the official story is built on lies and obfuscation.

Attribute	Details
Full Name	John O'Keefe
Date of Birth	(Information not publicly available)
Date of Death	January 29, 2022
Age at Death	46
Occupation	Boston Police Officer
Residence	Canton, Massachusetts
Relationship	Dating Karen Read since 2020
Cause of Death (Official)	Blunt impact injuries of head and hypothermia
Cause of Death (Defense Claim)	Dog attack and severe beating
Key Locations	34 Fairview Road, Canton, Massachusetts
Associated Individuals	Karen Read, Brian Albert, Chris Albert, Collin Albert, Frank Sheridan
Legal Case	Karen Read Murder Trial
Autopsy Information	Abrasions to right forearm, two black eyes, cut to nose, laceration to back of head, skull fractures, hemorrhaging of stomach and pancreas
Contested Evidence	Autopsy photos, dog bite marks, phone records
Allegations	Cover-up by police, framing of Karen Read
Reference Website	Boston.com

The defense has vehemently argued that the official account is a distortion of the truth, presenting an alternative narrative that places the blame on others. They contend that O'Keefe's death was not the result of a vehicular homicide, but rather a brutal attack that was then covered up to protect those involved. This claim is the cornerstone of their defense, one that challenges the very foundation of the prosecution's case. According to the defense's claim, OKeefe was murdered by his Massachusetts police colleagues.

The scene of the alleged crime, the home at 34 Fairview Road in Canton, owned by Brian Albert, a retired Boston Police Sergeant, becomes a focal point. The defense suggests the events unfolded differently from the prosecution's account. The defense team has even suggested that the injuries suffered by the victim were the result of a dog attack, not a car accident. Frank Sheridan, who inspected Johns body, determined the marks on his arm were dog bite marks.

Adding a layer of complexity, O'Keefe's past interactions with his neighbors, Chris and Collin Albert, come into play. Reports suggest a history of tension and even harassment between O'Keefe and the Alberts, including an instance of the Alberts sending him photos while he was on vacation. This prior conflict raises questions about potential motives and the possibility of pre-existing animosity.

The evidence presented by the defense, including graphic autopsy photos, is intended to support their claims and cast doubt on the prosecution's version of events. The defense has meticulously dissected the evidence, aiming to create reasonable doubt in the minds of the jurors. They argue that the injuries sustained by O'Keefe are inconsistent with being struck by a car. Instead, the defense asserts that O'Keefe was severely beaten, with injuries to both sides of his face and the back of his head.

The prosecution's case hinges on the assertion that Karen Read intentionally hit O'Keefe with her SUV, leaving him to die in the snow. However, the defense has presented a contrasting account of the events, suggesting that O'Keefe was the victim of a violent assault. Reads lawyers say autopsy photos show OKeefe was not hit by a car, but was severely beaten and had marks on his arms that appear to be dog bites. The legal team maintains that the autopsy photos and other evidence indicate that OKeefe was beaten severely, with injuries to both sides of his face and the back of his head. They further allege that wounds seen on OKeefes arms are consistent with dog bites.

The medical examiner, who performed the autopsy, initially ruled the manner of O'Keefe's death as "undetermined," according to his death certificate. This classification, one that can be classified five different ways on a death certificate, including accident and homicide, raises further questions about the official narrative.

One of the most contentious pieces of evidence presented by the defense involves the autopsy photos. The defense has pointed to these images as proof that O'Keefe's injuries were not consistent with being struck by a vehicle. The defense team claims that these photos and other evidence show OKeefe was beaten severely, with injuries to both sides of his face and the back of his head. They also allege wounds seen on OKeefes arms are consistent with dog bites. The presentation of such graphic evidence, including the publication of leaked photos, caused profound distress to O'Keefe's family. The family expressed deep pain upon the publication of leaked photos from the autopsy report.

Adding to the complexity, the defense is questioning the time frame of events and the movements of O'Keefe on the night of his death. They claim that OKeefes phone shows he went inside the home and traveled three flights of stairs inside the house. Moreover, the defense has suggested that the cars damage, the crime scene, and the evidence all point toward the fact that O'Keefe was not hit by a car.

The prosecution is relying on various pieces of evidence, including eight voicemails left by Karen Read. However, the defense is also drawing attention to other inconsistencies and potential pieces of evidence that support their claims. It is worth noting that the local reporter released a detailed article stating that the girlfriend was framed and it was actually other cops who killed O'Keefe. According to that report, the cops covered it up, along with their wives.

The case has attracted significant media attention, and one of the most painful moments for johns family was when turtleboys blog published leaked photos from the autopsy report, allowing morbidly curious readers to gawk at one of johns most.

The prosecution also faces the challenge of presenting evidence in a way that connects Karen Read directly to O'Keefe's death while addressing the defense's alternative narrative. The prosecution is expected to present autopsy photos of John OKeefe to the jury. The new police reports describe the morning scene when Read returned to the site of the party. Police encountered Read trying to give cpr to O'Keefe and screaming that he was dead.

As the trial continues, new evidence may emerge, and assumptions are being reconsidered. The legal battle surrounding John O'Keefe's death is far from over, and the quest for justice, along with the pursuit of truth, continues to unfold in the courtroom. The official story and the defense's version are diametrically opposed, and it is up to the jury to weigh the evidence and determine the true circumstances surrounding John O'Keefe's death.