Khloe Kardashian & OJ Simpson: Father Rumors & Family Ties - Explained

Dan Koss PhD 12 May 2025

Is it possible that the whispers, the speculation, the relentless chatter surrounding Khloe Kardashians parentage could actually be true? Despite denials from both sides, the persistent rumor that O.J. Simpson is Khloe Kardashian's biological father refuses to fade, continuing to fascinate and divide public opinion long after the initial seeds of doubt were sown.

On March 21, 2024, Khloe Kardashian was photographed in Los Angeles, California, her presence a constant reminder of the family drama that has played out in the public eye for decades. The recent passing of O.J. Simpson on April 11, 2024, has only served to amplify these long-standing rumors. The world continues to question the true nature of her parentage, even after the man at the center of the scandal, O.J. Simpson, has passed. Was there really a secret affair between Simpson and Kris Jenner, Khloe's mother, leading to this highly-publicized question mark on Khloe's life?

The narrative is complex, fueled by speculation and punctuated by denials from all involved. The relationship between O.J. Simpson and the Kardashian family is well-documented, with Robert Kardashian Sr., Khloe's father, serving as one of Simpson's defense attorneys during the infamous murder trial. This close association, combined with the physical similarities some perceive between Khloe and Simpson, has created a potent cocktail of suspicion and intrigue that has captivated the public's imagination for years.

Beyond the paternity question, the lives of Simpson's actual children have been profoundly affected by the events surrounding their father, and these long-standing rumors. Specifically, the lives of Arnelle and Jason Simpson, his children with his first wife, Marguerite Whitley, have been dramatically altered by the events surrounding their father. The tragic loss of Aaren Lashone, Marguerite's third child, who drowned in the family's pool before her second birthday, further underscores the emotional toll of these events.

Attribute	Details
Full Name	Arnelle Simpson
Known For	Daughter of O.J. Simpson
Date of Birth	Estimated around 1968 (Age: 55 as of 2024)
Parents	O.J. Simpson and Marguerite Whitley
Siblings	Jason Simpson, Aaren Lashone Simpson (deceased), Sydney Simpson, Justin Simpson
Relationship to Khloe Kardashian	Unrelated, despite persistent rumors
Public Appearances	Frequently seen with her father at events. Notably, she was present at the birthday celebration in June 2007.
Associated Individuals	O.J. Simpson, Kris Jenner, Robert Kardashian Sr., Nicole Brown Simpson
Notable Events	Her life has been significantly impacted by the events surrounding her father.
Reference	Biography.com

The core of the issue remains the alleged affair between Simpson and Kris Jenner. Robert Kardashian Sr., who later became Khloe's father, was also a close friend of Simpson, further intensifying the complexities. The Kardashian family's connection to Simpson, extending back to their college days, and Robert Kardashian's role as Simpson's defense attorney, all combined to create a web of relationships that has proven both enduring and provocative.

The media has consistently latched onto any potential evidence, be it the aforementioned physical similarities or the fact that Khloe and her family knew Simpson so well. In 2012, various gossip sites pointed to a photo of Khloe Kardashian with her family hair dresser, Alex Roldan, as supposed "proof" of Simpson's paternity. However, there are no credible sources to substantiate that claim. The rumour also was discussed on "Keeping Up With The Kardashians" where Kris and Khloe commented on this matter in season 7, episode 1 in 2012 titled as "Who's Your Daddy" and kris tried to convince Khloe.

Simpson himself, in his own way, addressed the rumors. While he thought the entire idea was "laughable," his response, which has evolved over time, didnt fully silence the speculation. The ambiguity left room for interpretation, further fueling the endless cycle of conjecture.

The focus on Khloe Kardashian obscures the experiences of Simpson's other children, specifically his daughters, Arnelle and Sydney, and son, Jason. Their lives, too, have been dramatically altered by the events surrounding their father. Their privacy has been invaded, and they have been forced to navigate the relentless media scrutiny that came with being associated with one of the most notorious figures in American history. Arnelle Simpson, in particular, has been thrust into the public eye on multiple occasions and has to deal with the constant spotlight on her. While the world remains captivated by the question of Khloe's paternity, it is crucial to remember that the lives of Simpsons other children have also been profoundly impacted.

The repeated denials from both Khloe Kardashian and O.J. Simpson, however, have done little to quell the whispers. Both Khloe and Simpson have spoken out, but the speculation continues.

The narrative is multi-layered. It involves close friends, a high-profile trial, and the constant glare of the public eye. The close relationship between Robert Kardashian Sr. and Simpson adds a layer of complexity to the story. Kardashian's role as Simpson's defense attorney, paired with the family's long-standing friendship, has further fueled the public's fascination.

The situation involves much more than just celebrity gossip. It is a complex entanglement of fame, family, and legal drama that continues to grip the public's attention. Simpson's other children, specifically Arnelle and Jason Simpson, have found their lives forever changed.

The infamous sports icon, O.J. Simpson, did offer his opinions on the matter when approached by TMZ. In 2012, gossip sites even went as far as to suggest that a photo of Khloe Kardashian with her family's hair dresser, Alex Roldan, was "proof" of Simpson's paternity. These claims, however, have not been verified.

There is a history here. Simpson's first wife, Marguerite Whitley, had three children with him. Their lives, along with the lives of Nicole Brown Simpson's children, Sydney and Justin, have been irrevocably altered by the events. Khloe Kardashian is not O.J. Simpson's child, but the rumors have persisted. Simpson's daughters are not the focus of these paternity rumors.

Its a saga marked by legal battles, family drama, and constant public scrutiny, a complex web of relationships and accusations that remains a captivating tale of our time. The question continues to reverberate. Is Khloe Kardashian really O.J. Simpson's daughter? The answer, while elusive, continues to dominate the headlines.